The purpose of California’s film tax credit is to encourage studios to create and retain production jobs in the state. Awarding a substantial tax credit to a company that immediately reduces its California workforce raises serious questions about whether the program is fulfilling that mission and whether stronger safeguards are needed to ensure taxpayers receive the public benefit these incentives are intended to provide.

As someone who spent years covering the animation industry, I’ve watched studios steadily dismantle California’s animation production base. These were private business decisions, and while I often disagreed with them, they were ultimately decisions for those companies to make.

This situation is different. By awarding Pixar a major state tax credit, California has made this a matter of public policy. As a resident of the state, I have a legitimate interest in how public resources are allocated and whether they achieve the public purpose for which they were intended. Every dollar the state devotes to a tax credit is a dollar that cannot be invested in the public services and infrastructure that affect my daily life and the lives of other Californians. {read}